RT Journal Article
SR Electronic
T1 To Forgive Is Divine? Morality and the Status Value of Intergroup Revenge and Forgiveness
JF RSF: The Russell Sage Foundation Journal of the Social Sciences
FD Russell Sage Foundation
SP 122
OP 139
DO 10.7758/RSF.2022.8.6.07
VO 8
IS 6
A1 Stephen Benard
A1 Long Doan
A1 D. Adam Nicholson
A1 Emily Meanwell
A1 Eric L. Wright
A1 Peter Lista
YR 2022
UL http://www.rsfjournal.org/content/8/6/122.abstract
AB Intergroup conflict is a costly and persistent aspect of social life, and one that often carries great moral significance for those who participate in it. Ostensibly moral behaviors can provide a path to social status in groups, as when self-sacrificing in-group members gain respect and prestige relative to their peers. This article bridges these two ideas to examine the perceived morality and status worthiness of intergroup revenge and forgiveness, and the moral accounts used to justify them. Using an original survey experiment conducted on a national probability sample in the United States, we examine everyday intergroup conflicts across national, sports, and political identities. We find forgiveness is perceived as more moral, and in turn more status worthy, than revenge. Justifications for moral judgments typically drew on accounts of harm/care, reciprocity, and avoiding chaos and disorder. This contributes to research on conflict, group dynamics, status, and morality.